Skip to main content

Song of Songs: Contrasting Two Approaches

I've almost finished my preliminary reading on the Song of Songs before I dive into serious study verse by verse. I wanted to take this post to contrast some approaches to the Song. The two primary approaches under discussion will be that of Exum and Garrett, though, towards the end I will also incorporate Longman's. The question is, what is the Song of Songs? The answer given by most everyone now is that it is erotic love poetry. Upon probing deeper, a variety of approaches emerge.

Once upon a time, it was common to read the Song as a dramatic poem. One variety saw it as a story of a love triangle between Solomon, the woman, and a shepherd. There aren't many proponents of these views anymore, however, the question of plot is still discussed. Does the Song (if it is a single poem) have any plot? If so to what degree? Garrett is one of the most vocal critics of the dramatic theories (80-1 in fact Garrett's introduction is one of the most negative towards other views that I've ever read in a commentary). That's why I found it so interesting that he sees a fair amount of plot in the Song. It's a poem about two lovers leading up to their wedding, and consummating it (111-3). He uses terms like 'protagonist' (for the woman) and 'quest' in his descriptions. The Song, to Garrett, is a poem about the woman's transformation from virgin and bound to wife and free. While perhaps less ambitious than the dramatic theories, I think it still falls into the same traps. There's not enough warrant in the text (at least based on my preliminary readings) to support this theory. More on this later.

Exum takes a much more restrained approach. There is a very strong stress throughout her introduction that the Song is lyric poetry. In effect, structure gets mistaken for plot. There arguably is an overarching structure to the Song, and there are repeated motifs and key words, but poetic development should not be mistaken for plot. There are stories told on the micro level, but there is no larger 'story' as far as we can tell (44).

I think that Exum is assuredly right here. This would be especially true if the suggestion of Longman (among others) is true (54-6). Do we have only one poem present here (as Exum thinks)? I am not so sure. We clearly have one poet, but this could be either one very long poem or a collection of multiple poems with an intentional arrangement. I write love poetry for my wife. You could take a selection of poems that I have written for her over the past decade and find a way, with minimal editing, to arrange them into a coherent whole. Since the characters remain constant, you could probably string together a basic plot (some of my poems clearly refer to key events like engagement, the birth of our child, etc.). It would seem as if there was a plot. But that would be a misreading of the poems as poems.

Is the Song a unity? I'm not sure. I'll dive into that more as I study the individual units. However, reading for plot seems to be clearly a mistake, at least to me.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Exploring the Christian Way of Life - The Identity of Jesus - Church History (Pre-Reformation) - Aquinas and Conclusion

When we reach Aquinas we come to the pinnacle of orthodoxy when it comes to the Trinity and Christology. Christology was important to Aquinas and he dedicated the first fifty-nine questions of Tertia Pars of his Summa Theologiae[1] to the topic. In many ways it is refreshing because he does not treat solely the more philosophical questions of who Jesus was that preoccupied theologians from the third century on. He also spent extended time on Jesus earthly ministry, death, resurrection, ascension, and glorification which was a major innovation.[2] Of course every possible topic of Trinitarian and ontological speculation is also probed. For the sake of space we will only hit some highlights.

Aquinas is clearly in step with the tradition that can be traced from Nicea, through Augustine and the Lombard, to the heart of the Middle Ages. One thing to briefly note is that even in his densest argumentation, Aquinas was not trying to prove elements of his theology via rational argument as that…

Exploring the Christian Way of Life - The Identity of Jesus - Church History (Pre-Reformation) - Irenaeus

Starting from Irenaeus, Christology, in some respects, moves on. A big part of this would have been due to the “gnostic” controversies. It became increasingly important to clarify the relationship between Father and Son and to minimize their distinctiveness, while still maintaining Jesus’ full humanity. From this point on, clashes over heresy about the nature of Christ and discussions related to Trinitarian theology dominate Christological discussion to the point that the original emphasis on Jesus’ Messianic identity fades to the background.[1] Maintaining the affirmation that Jesus was both human and divine was critical for Irenaeus and those after him because they saw that as the necessary grounds of salvation.[2]

Of particular interest to Irenaeus was the baptism of Jesus. What happened when he received the Spirit?[3] It was not the means by which the Word entered Jesus. He was not merely human before that point.[4] Rather it was a divinization of the human nature of Jesus, a nat…

End of Summer Review/Update

The school year is now upon us and I'll definitely not be posting the next two months. This summer didn't quite go to plan so I didn't get to do the blogging I was hoping to do. Specifically I was planning on blogging through 2 Thessalonians, but that didn't happen. It may happen late in the fall, but we will see. I may instead decide to pick up a different Pauline letter (perhaps 2 Corinthians). This is my last year of school  and by the fall of next year I should be back on a more regular blogging schedule.

A lack of blogging was not from a lack of productivity (although I'm sure my Pokemon Go playing did cut into my reading time a little bit). I've had a interesting summer learning about Medieval Christianity and specifically focusing on Peter Lombard and Thomas Aqunias. They'll both be featured in my next paper in Exploring the Christian Way which I hope to publish here in late January of 2017. 90% of the reading and 80% of the writing is done for that …